While Buffy is at the high school getting her things, she is confronted by Caleb. She attacks him and is beaten unconscious. Meanwhile, Faith takes the Potentials to the Bronze to unwind. Cops show up and attempt to exact Hellmouth-like justice on Faith. Buffy shows up and sends everyone home. When she tells them that she has a new plan to attack the vinyard, everyone rallies against her and votes Faith as their new leader. Things get worse when Dawn asks her to leave.